Cortical Thinning in High-Grade Asymptomatic Carotid Stenosis

Article information

J Stroke. 2023;25(1):92-100

Publication date (electronic) : 2023 January 3

doi : https://doi.org/10.5853/jos.2022.02285

Randolph S. Marshall^,a, David S. Liebeskind^b, John Huston III^c, Lloyd J. Edwards^d, George Howard^d, James F. Meschia^e, Thomas G. Brott^e, Brajesh K. Lal^f, Donald Heck^g, Giuseppe Lanzino^h, Navdeep Sanghaⁱ, Vikram S. Kashyap^j, Clarissa D. Morales^a, Dejania Cotton-Samuel^a, Andres M. Rivera^a, Adam M. Brickman^a, Ronald M. Lazar^k

^aDepartment of Neurology, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY, USA

^bDepartment of Neurology, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA

^cDepartment of Radiology, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA

^dDepartment of Biostatistics, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA

^eDepartment of Neurology, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL, USA

^fDepartment of Surgery, University of Maryland, Baltimore, MD, USA

^gDepartment of Radiology, Novant Health Clinical Research, Winston-Salem, NC, USA

^hDepartment of Neurologic Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA

ⁱDepartment of Neurology, Kaiser Permanente Los Angeles Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA

^jDepartment of Surgery, University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA

^kDepartment of Neurology, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, AL, USA

Correspondence: Randolph S. Marshall Department of Neurology, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, 710 W 168th St, New York, NY 10032, USA Tel: +1-212-305-8389 Fax: +1-212-305-3741 E-mail: rsm2@columbia.edu

Received 2022 July 13; Revised 2022 October 15; Accepted 2022 October 17.

Abstract

Introduction

High-grade carotid artery stenosis may reduce cerebral perfusion in the hemisphere ipsilateral to the stenosis by 8% to 24% [1,2]. Other hemodynamic measures, such as a relative delay in arrival time of contrast material to the hemisphere supplied by the stenotic carotid artery, may be seen in up to 50% of patients [3,4]. Although hemodynamic impairment is associated with increased risk of stroke [5,6] and cognitive dysfunction [7-9], the consequence of these hemodynamic abnormalities on brain structure is not currently known. Cortical thinning is an imaging marker associated with cognitive impairment [10], seen in patients with traumatic brain injury [11], neurodegeneration [12,13], and cerebrovascular disease [14-16]. In this study, we investigated the effect of hemodynamic impairment on cortical thickness in patients with unilateral, high-grade, asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis.

The Carotid Revascularization and Medical Management for Asymptomatic Carotid Stenosis–Hemodynamics (CREST-H) is a National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS)-funded clinical investigation, ancillary to the NINDS-funded Carotid Revascularization and Medical Management for Asymptomatic Carotid Stenosis Study (CREST-2) randomized clinical trial [17]. CREST-2 is a pair of outcome-blinded, phase 3 randomized clinical trials to assess treatment differences in stroke and death rates in patients assigned to: (1) carotid endarterectomy (CEA) plus intensive medical management (IMM) versus IMM alone, and (2) carotid artery stenting (CAS) plus IMM versus IMM alone [18]. CREST-H is designed to determine if a subset of CREST-2 patients with high-grade, asymptomatic carotid artery stenosis and hemodynamic impairment would demonstrate cognitive benefit by revascularization of the stenotic carotid artery by CEA or CAS (clinicaltrials.gov NCT03121209). For this report, we used baseline imaging data from the CREST-H study to investigate whether degree of hemodynamic impairment as measured by time-to-peak (TTP) delay in the hemisphere ipsilateral to the stenotic carotid artery correlated with relative cortical thinning in that hemisphere. We hypothesized that patients enrolled in CREST-2 and CREST-H with severe carotid occlusive disease but without recent stroke would show cortical thinning in the hemisphere ipsilateral to the side of the stenosis prior to treatment onset (baseline) if there was hemodynamic impairment in that hemisphere. Because the CREST-H and CREST-2 clinical trials are still ongoing, there are additional imaging and cognitive outcomes data that remain blinded. These will be analyzed for publication at a later date. The present study contains baseline data currently available for analysis.

Methods

Results

There were 110 participants included in the study. As shown in Table 1, average age was 70.2±7.8 years, 61% male. Eighty-five percent had hypertension, mean HbA1c=6.1%, mean LDL cholesterol=79.1 mg/dL, 64% were current or prior smokers, and 47% had left sided stenosis. Twenty-four percent of participants reported a history of prior stroke, and 44% had infarctions on structural MR imaging, ranging in size from 3 mm to 74 mm in largest diameter (average=10.5±10 mm). Of the 110 participants, one had inadequate perfusion imaging and two others had incomplete structural imaging, thus 107 were included in the regression analysis. The distribution of TTP delay across the 109 participants with perfusion imaging and cortical thickness measurements is shown in Figure 1. Of these, 64 (59%) had no TTP asymmetry, 45 (41%) had TTP delay of at least 0.5 seconds. With increasing TTP delay thresholds, fewer subjects were represented, with 9 (8.3%) subjects having TTP delay of at least 2.0 seconds. Of note, no subjects included in the study had TTP greater than 4.0 seconds.

Table 1.

Demographic, medical, and radiographic characteristics of the study subjects

Figure 1.

Histogram showing the distribution of time-to-peak (TTP) delays among 109 subjects, with n=64 (59%) having no delay (0.00–0.49 sec), the remainder having TTP delay ≥0.5 seconds. Nine patients (8.3%) had TTP delay ≥2.0 seconds. Number of subjects in each TTP category is shown above the bars.

Our primary goal was to determine whether there was an association between degree of TTP delay and cortical thickness asymmetry between the ipsilateral and the contralateral hemisphere. Results for this multivariable model are shown in Table 2, which represents the fully adjusted model, including all variables. Our findings demonstrate that TTP delay was an independent predictor of cortical thickness asymmetry (P=0.032), indicating that relative hemodynamic impairment on the side of the stenosis was associated with relative cortical thinning on the ipsilateral side relative to the contralateral side. The relationship between degree of TTP delay and mean cortical thickness asymmetry is illustrated in Figure 2, based on the unadjusted model: the greater the TTP delay, the greater the asymmetry in cortical thickness. For every 0.25 second increase in TTP delay, there is a 0.006 mm (6 micron) increase in cortical thickness asymmetry. The magnitude of the difference in thickness between the 2 hemispheres averaged 0.025 mm (25 microns) at TTP delay of 2 seconds (approximately 1% of mean cortical thickness of the human brain) [25]. The association between TTP delay and cortical thickness asymmetry remained significant in the presence of infarction. As shown in Table 2, hypertension, left vs. right hemisphere and contralateral infarction were also associated with cortical thickness asymmetry. Of note, in all analyses we chose to use the binary variable for infarct because it provided a natural cut-point for interpretation (≥10 mm diameter for cortical infarcts and ≥15 mm for subcortical infarcts). In addition, the distribution of infarct volumes was highly skewed; a majority of patients had no infarct at all (infarct volume=0) in either the ipsilateral hemisphere (n=74, 69%) or the contralateral hemisphere (n=78, 73%). This violates assumptions for linear regression. Using infarct as a continuous variable, which would incorporate the skew, the P-value for TTP was nonsignificant (P=0.074).

Table 2.

Independent predictors of cortical thickness asymmetry by linear regression model

Figure 2.

Linear regression line showing the relationship between time-to-peak (TTP) delay and cortical thickness asymmetry in the unadjusted model. A positive slope indicates that the greater the TTP delay (greater relative TTP delay in the hemisphere ipsilateral to the carotid stenosis) the greater the relative thinning of the cortex in that hemisphere. Dashed lines indicate the 95% confidence intervals.

Discussion

Cortical thinning, an imaging marker associated with cognitive decline, is found in different brain pathologies, including neurodegenerative diseases, traumatic brain injury, demyelinating disease, and stroke [10-16,26]. It also occurs with normal aging [10]. Associations between cerebral hemodynamic impairment and some of these conditions have been reported. In stroke, cognitive dysfunction has been reported when ipsilateral flow velocities are reduced in the middle cerebral artery [7] or when there is impaired cerebrovascular vasoreactivity [8,9]. The question has remained unsettled, however, whether cerebral hemodynamic impairment can be a contributing factor in cortical thinning. At least one carotid study showed no correlation between degree of stenosis, cortical thickness, and cognition, although no hemodynamic measurement was made in that study [27]. When reduced cerebral blood flow has been identified in the setting of neurodegeneration, cortical flow reduction is thought to be a consequence of reduced metabolism in the thinner cortex [28]. In the current study, we showed that relative cortical thinning was associated with hemispheric TTP delay on the side of asymptomatic high-grade carotid artery stenosis and so it is plausible to infer that the thinning might have been a consequence of chronic hemodynamic impairment.

Vascular cognitive impairment is widely described clinically as a step-wise or progressive condition resulting from accumulated ischemic injury [29,30]. Cerebral hemodynamic failure in patients with high-grade carotid artery stenosis can also impair cognition, even if no overt clinical stroke has occurred. This has been shown with measures of resting cerebral blood flow and metabolism [31], with low middle cerebral artery mean flow velocity [7], and with impaired vasoreactivity [8,9], contributing independently to cognitive decline either directly [32], or as a consequence of silent infarction [33]. Whether cognitive function can improve with restored flow is also unclear. Recent case series showed cognitive improvement after carotid endarterectomy or stenting [34-36], but the hypothesis has never been tested in the context of a randomized clinical trial. We recently found that the baseline cognitive profile of the first 1,000 patients in the CREST-2 trial is diminished relative to control participants from the Reasons for Geographic And Racial Differences in Stroke (REGARDS) study, matched for age, education, and comorbidity [37]. In rodent studies of ischemia, experimental occlusion of large arteries has been reported to produce selective neuronal loss [38] and thinning of the neuropil [39]. It is unknown whether cellular correlates of cortical thinning are the same for human subjects as for animal models. The magnitude of the cortical thickness asymmetry in the current study was quite small and could be consistent with selective cellular loss. For context, the diameter of a human red blood cell is about 8 microns, and the diameter of a human hair is about 70 microns. Nonetheless, the magnitude of thinning we identified in this study is equivalent to about a decade of aging in normal healthy adults, as shown in a high-resolution MRI study of 106 healthy subjects, age 18–93 [40]. Cortical thinning occurred on average at a rate of 0.016 mm (16 microns) per decade [40]. Thus, the ipsilateral cortical thickness we observed in a 75-year-old subject from our study with a TTP delay of 2 seconds would be the equivalent of the thickness we might expect if that subject were 85 years old and had no carotid disease.

Patients in this study were required to be asymptomatic for stroke or TIA within the preceding 6 months, but 26 (24%) reported a history of stroke >6 months before, and 47 (44%) had radiographic evidence of ischemic infarctions on structural MR imaging. Because both cortical [41] and subcortical [14] infarction have been associated with cortical thinning, we tested whether the presence of infarction could explain our findings. Adjusting for ipsilateral and contralateral infarction, the association between TTP delay and cortical asymmetry remained significant, supporting an independent role of hemodynamic impairment in the pathophysiology of cortical thinning. Our data also showed that contralateral infarction was independently associated with cortical thinning asymmetry, with relative thinning in the contralateral hemisphere; that is, there was a negative correlation between contralateral infarct and cortical thickness asymmetry in our model. An interpretation would be that relative cortical thinning in the ipsilateral hemisphere was affected by both hemodynamic impairment and infarction, whereas in the contralateral hemisphere where there was no hemodynamic impairment, the thinning was driven predominantly by infarction. Hemisphere side was also independently associated with cortical thickness asymmetry, presumably due to the left hemisphere being dominant in most patients [40].

Limitations for this study include the small number of participants, although the study had positive findings with 110 subjects. We also did not have information about the duration of hemodynamic impairment in each subject, nor data on directional flow across the circle of Willis to assess collateral status. Finally, we recognize that TTP delay is not equivalent to measuring hypoperfusion by relative cerebral blood flow (rCBF). Much of the information about the impact of hemodynamic impairment has come in the setting of acute stroke. TTP delay of ≥2 seconds is well described in regions with low rCBF in the infarct core and penumbra, and both TTP and MTT have been shown to be sensitive markers of hemodynamic impairment [42,43]. In the chronic setting, correlations between TTP delay and rCBF have been inconsistent [44], although one recent study showed concordant reduced rCBF and delayed TTP in 16 of 18 patients with high-grade unilateral carotid stenosis [45]. TTP itself has also been shown to be highly predictive of subsequent vascular events in carotid stenosis, including for TIA [46], hyperperfusion syndrome after CAS [47], and poor stroke outcomes [21]. Thus both TTP delay and reduced rCBF may be considered part of hemodynamic pathophysiology. Our findings are consistent with a prior study showing significant cortical volume loss after a mean 3.9 years in patients with severe or bilateral high-grade carotid stenosis [48]. Additional information about the evolution of the hemodynamic effect as well as correlations with cognition will be assessed using longitudinal data from this cohort once the clinical trial is completed and cognitive data are fully unblinded. Demonstration of the baseline cognition in the first 1,000 patients in the CREST-2 trial confirmed that this asymptomatic, high-grade stenosis population was a plausible substrate to examine the hemodynamic associations in this study [37].

Conclusions

Our study showed an association between hemodynamic impairment and relative cortical thinning in the hemisphere ipsilateral to asymptomatic high-grade carotid artery stenosis. A causal relationship will require further validation. Although our findings indicated that there are several variables that may contribute to cortical thinning, the hemodynamic association remained significant after adjusting for the presence of other variables including prior infarction. Our findings thus suggest that cortical thinning in this population may be a consequence of chronic hemodynamic impairment. As an imaging marker associated with cognitive decline, identification of cortical thinning may have implications for the management of asymptomatic high-grade carotid artery disease. Whether revascularization can mitigate or reverse cognitive decline is an essential question that remains to be determined and is the primary hypothesis being tested in the ongoing CREST-H study.

Article information Continued